Monday, 6 February 2012 | Now viewing:  WineChap
Switch to: UK | NYC | Hong Kong |

Sketch Lecture Room

Share

Last updated: August 16, 2010

Address:
9 Conduit Street, London, W1S 2XG
Phone:
0207 659 4500
Website:
Rating:
Good For:
Mature vintages, Champagne, Old World, French

Rating Breakdown:
Range of wines: 19/20
Personality: 20/20
Value for money: 7/10
Rating Total: 46/50

List Summary

Sketch's list is a salve for cynicism. It refreshes our belief in humanitys (or at least sommeliers) earnest desire to strive for excellence and individuality, whilst not forgetting that the worlds less fortunate also deserve to drink reasonably. Dotted throughout the Lecture Rooms showy list there are some extremely inexpensive bottles (starting at £16) which snootier restaurants (mentioning absolutely nobody really quite close by) might shun like ones socially and physically maladroit provincial second cousins at the races. However, this is an impeccably-mannered list; condescending to accept the vulgarity of ones inferiors is far less vulgar than ones exclusion of them.

The opening short list (by the glass selection) is an impressive mission statement and one initially wonders if sommelier Fred Bruges can possibly maintain the intensity of elegance (and eloquence) throughout.
Of course we love having tasting notes for the 8 mineral waters offered although why not go to town and list something like the 9-stage filtered Bling h20 (40 retail) for fun. Come on its Sketch after all! If anyone will buy it, it will be here. Its great to see Palo Cortado by the glass and how can you not want to hug a list that offers glasses of 1850 Madeira (at 122) with the note The year Balzac died and Lizst conducted the Premier of Lohengrin was a great one for Verdelho.
In fact the whole by the glass offering is peerless with dainty 100ml options offered alongside more generous 175ml measures. For 44 you can have small glass of Fonseca 77 probably the least anyone will ever have to pay for a 100 point wine (Wine Spectator, Jan 08).

Champagne is an undoubted strength with the more exotic cuvees of favoured Marques intertwined with top independent grower wines. They are obviously working to tight margins because the majority seem, if not affordable, but fairly-priced.
Almost as if Fred cannot bear to leave Champagne, the whites list starts refreshingly with a trio from the Coteaux Champenois before heading in to a respectable if generally rather young Burgundy selection, punctuated by a few well-priced jewels.

White Bordeaux gets a nod and then we are in to an engaging and affordable Loire section with Chenin Blanc refreshingly well-represented among the Sancerres/PFs and top-end Dagueneau library with which it concludes. Concerning the rest of France, the most judicious choices and best value are from the Jura and Savoie, Provence and Corsica, and the South West in particular.
Italy and Spain offer more generic choices from well-established boutique producers and then are lean but fine choices from Germany and Portugal. The fabulous and oft-overlooked dry whites of Hungary get a brief acknowledgment with three listings from the peerless Istvan Szepsy. Notable from the rest of the world is Australias homage to Giaconda at the top end and the listing of Bernard Magrez unusual Koshu Isehara from Japan.

Red Burgundy and Bordeaux are unusually but refreshingly organised price ascending, rather than by any regional sub-division and this makes sense: Most of us have in mind an approximate wine-spend so it is more convenient to have all of those in preferred bracket listed together rather than searching through multiple sections. Choices from the Loire are excitingly esoteric and well-sourced and both the Southern Rhone and Languedoc and Roussillon selections are particularly extensive with some good value options.

Italy, like a Huntsman suit from The Row opposite is slim-fit and individually tailored, with recognition of the greats but some more recondite choices for the cognoscenti. The Spanish selection, whilst not inexpensive is worth looking at, especially for the peppering of trendy Priorat wines and the almost wicked glee concluding the tasting note for Pingus first vintage, the US allocation of the 95 was lost in a shipwreck.
South Africa and Chile offer the best value options from the small New World list and Argentinas three choices are devoted to Fabre Montmayous fine Malbecs.

The list concludes with a strong choice of Dessert wines, magnums and larger formats still, wrapped around one of Londons most extensive selection of half-bottles.


List Review Wine Key:
Sparkling
White
Rose
Red
Sweet
Fortified

By The Glass
Most interesting available by the glass }
2004 Saumur, Breze, Les Clos, Guiberteau, Loire Valley | £14
2007 Riesling, Kabinett, Scharzhofberger, Egon Müller, Germany (175ml) | £21.50
Lovely, light and lifted (if a little pricey)
2001 Coteaux du Languedoc, Mas Jullien | £28.50
1977 Vintage Port, Fonseca (100ml) | £44
Some of the by the glass options may seem a bit pricey, but this is a great opportunity to try some superlative wines where buying the whole bottle might break the bank. With such an exceptional range of halves, why buy just a glass anyway?
By The Half
Most interesting available by the half bottle }
2004 Ch Smith-Haut-Laffite, Pessac-Léognan, Bordeaux | £64
Fresh and juicy grapefruit notes, with subtle hints of exotic fruit and a firm, full structure.
2008 Penedes, Chardonnay, Augustus Forum, Spain | £28
2004 Amarone, Zenato, Veneto, Italy | £51
2005 Macon Cruzille, Les Beaumont, Guillot Broux, Burgundy | £25
A lovely expression of Gamay, plenty of red fruits, but hints of pepper and laurel too.
Value Option
Best under £35/$50/bottom 20% of list PLUS any particularly rare bargains at ANY price point }
2007 Douro, Duas Quintas, Ramos-Pinto | £28
Native grapes but resembling a warm but perky Southern Rhone or Provencal white
2007 Chardonnay, Vins de Pays, Vignoble Guillaume | £23
An excellent wine from a producer who specifically acts as a nursery for many fine wineries in Burgundy it is more like a well-nurtured young prodigy than an over-exposed X Factor runner-up whose 15minutes in the spotlight has turned them to methadone addiction and club night appearances in Rotherham.
2007 Fiano, Mandrarossa, Settesoli, Sicily | £16
2004 Bourgogne-Chitry, Alice et Olivier de Moor | £35
2004 Cahors, Zette, Ch Lagrezette, South West France | £21
2003 Jumilla Monastrell, Casa Castillo, Spain | £27
A lovely and smooth textured red with flavours of raspberry and hints of chocolate. Great value.
2004 Duas Quintas, Ramos-Pinto, Douro | £27
1st Date
Impressive but not too showy: circa £50 – but a wine that shows one’s connoisseurship rather than just size of wallet/expense account }
Jacquesson, Cuvee 733, Champagne | £60
A mouth-watering and clean nose of rose petal and lemon peel gives way to an intense, full and broad palate. They stake a claim to being the oldest independent Champagne House (founded in 1798), allegedly their wines found favour with Napoleon who said "I drink Champagne when I win, to celebrate and I drink Champagne when I lose, to console myself." So if bubbles aren't enough to make your 1st date go swimmingly, at least you have the Champagne!
2007 Givry, Clos de la Servoisine, Joblot, Burgundy | £53
Dominated by appealing flavours of apples and pears this shows terrific purity and focus. A relatively tiny, but notable domaine of the Côte Chalonnaise.
2007 Cassis, Clos Ste Magdelaine, Provence | £54
A blend of Marsanne, Ugni Blanc, Clairette and Sauvignon; the wine shows understated aromatics of white flowers and honeysuckle leading to a rich palate of apricot, honey and and butter, with a touch of citrus. Sainte Magdelaine is said to be one of the top producers in Cassis and this wine is a good indication of how it earned this reputation.
2003 Bandol, Domaine de Terrebrune, Provence, France | £50
Jammy red fruits dominate, but this is not a confected red. Subtle hints of liquorice, chick peas and nuts give added layers of complexity. The Domaine uses only organic farming for its vineyard and every effort is made not only to respect the terroir, but to express it.
2004 Rioja, Allende, Spain | £52
2004 St Joseph, Les Royes, Courbis, Northern Rhône, France | £61
Off the Beaten Track
Egly-Ouriet, Les Vignes de Vrigny, Premier Cru, Extra Brut, Blanc de Noirs | £89
100% Pinot Meurnier, made from 40+ yr old vines in Vrigny, located on the Petite Montaigne de Reims. An exceptionally intense Pinot Meurnier, soft, creamy yet very dry. (NB Egly-Ouriet is one of Robert Parkers 13 top 5 Star Champagne houses, along with Krug, Bollinger, Salon and other, mostly well-known names.)
1999 Bollinger, Vielles Vignes Francaises Grand Cru | £710
A WineChap favourite and utterly original? phyloxera-resistant Pinot Noir from two Grand Cru sites in Ay that grow 'en foule' in their sandy soils - i.e. the vines grow singly and upright and are left to create their own next growth from the canes beneath the ground. Fascinating ? and the results are magnificent.
2005 Montlouis Sec, Remus, La Taille aux Loups, Jacky Blot | £60
Golden fruits with a hint of savoury smokiness, the lightly honeyed and minerally nose belies the fat ripeness of the palate. Although the domaine de la Taille aux Loups has failed to attain the same high profile as some of its neighbours, the care (bordering on obsession) taken in all aspects of the wines production, has resulted in exceptional wines.
2006 Ribolla Gialla, RoncAlto, Collio (Friuli) | £43
A rare and racy indigenous varietal, and from the best hillside area of the region.
2005 Arneis, Seghesio, Russian River Valley | £39
Known for their Zinfandel (itself a very close relative of Italy's Primitivo) the Italian connection continues with this well-made rarity Piemonte's most interesting white varietal.
2007 Touraine, In Cot We Trust, Thierry Puzelat | £42
Old school - the wine of musketeers and the Bourbon dynasty. Unadulterated malbec that should be served in goblets by musky serving wenches.
2001 Bolgheri, Paleo Rosso, Le Macchiole | £97
The first 100% Cabernet Franc from this most elegant of Super Tuscan producers - I seem to recall Jancis Robinson referring to the '01 as the "Cheval Blanc of Bolgheri"
2007 Torrontes de Otono, Laborum, El Porvenir de los Andes, Cafayete (50cl) | £104
An unusual sweet and unctuous late harvest Torrontes.
Old School Classic
Classic (usually French or Italian – depending on dominant cuisine), from the middle of the list – a good wine, with age to stick on expenses and impress crusty wine bores/board members }
1996 Pol Roger, Champagne | £127
2000 Meursault, Leroy, Burgundy | £122
2005 Cornas, Chaillot, Allemand, Northern Rhône, France | £121
2005 Savigny-lès-Beaune, La Dominode, Bruno Clair | £116
1989 Ch Rieussec, Sauternes, Bordeaux | £104
Treat Yourself
Remember when you used to get a bonus? not necessarily most expensive – but a real treat, rare, particularly good vintage etc }
Larmandier-Bernier, Terre de Vertus, Grand Cru, Brut Z | £99
At just £99 this isn't too much of a budget breaker to treat yourself with, but this is an exceptionally focused and distinctive wine; given the opportunity to open up it reveals interlacing layers of apricot, light acacia honey (in spite of the zero dosage) and graphite, cut through with energy and bright grapefruit flavours. This is certainly a complex champagne and a little off the beaten track, but the philosophy of Pierre and Sophie Larmandier is one to appreciate; they have a natural approach to viticulture, not for reasons of tradition, just because it makes sense, with a passionate belief in terroir. The result? A range of pure, expressive and unique champagnes, it doesn't always have to be all about the Grande Marques! (Biodynamic; 100% Chardonnay)
1985 Riesling, Kastelberg, Marc Kreydenweiss, Alsace | £202
Rarely do we find the opportunity to try mature Riesling; Marc Kreydenweiss has been producing wine in Alsace since the early 1970's and has long been an exponent of organic wine making. Showing excellent depth and complexity, it has a subtly oily texture with surprisingly fresh minerality and a long finish.
2000 Hermitage, Jean-Louis Chave, Northern Rhone | £301
An unctuous and almost oleaginous texture, highly aromatic and a terrifically rich palate; honeysuckle, white flowers, stone fruits and citrus make up this Rousanne dominated blend. No wonder we love white Rhone.
2006 Chardonnay, Giaconda, Beechworth, Australia | £251
This wine has developed something of a cult following and it's not hard to see why. It may lack some of the subtlety that aficionados of Burgundy love, yet the intense aromas and flavors are all perfectly proportioned. Think exceptional big band, rather than Philharmonic; boasting tight minerality with yeasty overtones, the creamy palate bursts with notes of peach and lemon sherbet.
1945 Ch Clos de Sharpe, St Emilion, Bordeaux | £286
Arguably the greatest vintage of the last century - a very rare chance to weigh in with an opinion for under £300.
1994 Chateauneuf-du-Pape, Hommage a Jacques Perrin, Ch de Beaucastel | £342
Following in the wake of a couple of truly sublime vintages (Robert Parker awarded the '89 and the '90 100 pints apiece), the '94 does not shine out quite so brightly, but it's still an exceptional wine showing its own unique style. Less fruit driven than previous vintages, this has a far meatier personality, black currant and cherry fruits are present, but underpinned by more savoury vegetal and beef notes.
1978 Solaia, Antinori, Tuscany, Italy | £1248
"The Sunny one" Solaia was first released in 1978 as blend of 80% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Cabernet Franc (this has now been amended to 75% Cab Sauv, 20% Sangiovese and 5% Cab Franc). This wine could almost be considered a collectors piece, representing Antinori's innovation in the Super-Tuscan revolution of the 70's, but to do anything other than imbibe would be a shameful waste. Mature, but not tired, this is complex and as multi-layered as Stephen Hawking's view of the universe; elegant spicy green leather and cigar box notes with savoury smoky balsamic hints are balanced by an attractive underlying sweetness.
Infanticide
Wines being sold too young, and a prime indicator of sommelier’s integrity. Usually found towards the expensive end of a list with big names thrown in for several or more hundred pounds despite being years off drinking to that price. }
2007 Corton Charlemagne, Coche Dury | £649
2004 Barolo, Enrico VI, Cordero de Montezemolo (magnum) | £256
Crowd pleaser
Well known, trusted producer, region or varietal. No surprises, no disappointments }
2007 Sauvignon Blanc, Clos Henri, Marlborough | £46
2006 L'Explorateur, Colonial Estate, Barossa Valley | £43
This is a classic ripe Aussie Shiraz, but lifted by an especially velvety texture.
Rutherglen Muscat, Campbells, Victoria, Australia | £28
An exceptionally popular, fruit driven sweet wine.
House Wine Index
Number of House wines available by the glass & the mean price }
N/A
Bollinger Index
Price of a bottle Bollinger }
N/A